Login
|
Subscribe
GO
Search only accepts letters and numbers.
Sunday, February 17, 2019
Home
News
Columns
Brian Howey
Cameron Carter
Linda Chezem
Joshua Claybourn
Jack Colwell
Larry DeBoer
Craig Dunn
Trevor Foughty
Shaw Friedman
Lee Hamilton
Christina Hale
Maureen Hayden
Michael Hicks
Rich James
Terri Jett
David Kitchell
Robert Kraft
Erin Macey
Morton Marcus
Jay Ruckleshaus
Chris Sautter
Mark Schoeff Jr.
Pete Seat
Russ Stilwell
Mark Souder
Tony Samuel
Renee Wilmeth
Downloads
HPI Daily Wire
HPI Weekly PDF's
HPI Polling
HPI Poll April 23, 2013
Howey/DePauw Poll November 2, 2012
Howey-Gauge Poll October 28, 2008
Howey/DePauw Poll September 27, 2012
Howey/DePauw Poll May 4, 2012
Howey/DePauw Poll April 5, 2012
Howey-Gauge Poll September 4, 2008
Howey-Gauge Poll April 29, 2008
Member's Archives
2014 Archives - PDF's
2013 Archives - PDF'S
2012 Archives - PDF's
2011 Archives - PDF's
2010 Archives - PDF's
2009 Archives - PDF's
2008 Archives - PDF's
2007 Archives - PDF's
2006 Archives - PDF's
2005 Archives - PDF's
2004 Archives - PDF's
2003 Archives - PDF's
2002 Archives - PDF's
2001 Archives - PDF's
2000 Archives - PDF's
HPI Videos
About
Contact
Subscribe
Shaw Friedman: Donald Trump, Judge Curiel and Hoosier lawyers
By SHAW FRIEDMAN
Saturday, June 4, 2016 10:20 AM
Federal Judge Gonzalo Curiel is an East Chicago native and a graduate of the Indiana University Law School.
LaPORTE, Ind. – The notion that this hopeless narcissist and racist, Donald Trump, has just captured the nomination of his beloved Republican Party would certainly cause the consummate modest gentleman and country doctor – Doc Bowen – to roll over in his grave.
For many of us Democrats growing up in Indiana, kindly Doc Bowen represented a gentle and courtly manner of Republicanism who, while having political beliefs different than our own, treated friend and foe alike with respect and civility.
The same can be said for the one of the greatest living statesmen of our time, Richard Lugar, who always practiced courtesy and respect to those who differed with him and became the model of diplomacy both in the U.S. Senate and in international circles. I confess to some bias about the former senator as he’s still the greatest living member of my fraternity, Beta Theta Pi, and a world-respected model of cordiality and of respect for the law and our democratic processes.
Contrast that with the pathetic spectacle we’ve seen in just the last few days as Donald Trump has chosen to hit a new low with his attacks on U.S. District Court Judge Gonzalo Curiel of Southern California. Just when you’re confident that Trump has sunk as low as he can go, he chose in a fit of uncontained fury to attack the judge hearing one of the class action cases alleging fraud by the now-defunct Trump University.
As part of Trump’s “grudge” tour after claiming the nomination, he took an astounding 12 minutes of his campaign speech last Friday to demand that Judge Curiel recuse himself because he was a “hater” and “very hostile” to Trump and should “be ashamed of himself. ” Trump complained about “getting railroaded” by a “rigged” legal system while mentioning Curiel was nominated by President Obama. He conveniently neglected the fact that Curiel’s nomination was approved unanimously by the U.S. Senate on Sept. 22, 2012, on a voice vote with not a single Republican voting in opposition.
Trump then went on to slam the judge as “Mexican” seeking to elicit whoops and hollers from his crowd as if attacking yet another immigrant. Again, Trump’s pathetic habit of lying about opponents and anyone he perceives as hostile or critical of him was in plain view yet again. As has been written by our publisher, Judge Curiel is not from Mexico, but is a native Hoosier, having been born in East Chicago, Ind., before attending and graduating I.U. Law School.
This disgusting excuse for a national candidate utterly refused to acknowledge that when Curiel moved to California, he served as a distinguished assistant U.S. attorney for the Central District of California and was so intimately involved in drug prosecutions that he was actually a target of drug cartel death squads for having sought to extradite two drug kingpins from Mexico. Curiel was so highly thought of for his work with the U.S. attorney’s office that he was appointed to a California Superior Court vacancy by then Republican Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.
Raising Curiel’s status as a Mexican-American and trying to point to his ethnicity as a means to debase this honored son of Indiana is the last refuge of a scoundrel. I cannot believe that my fellow Hoosier lawyers of whatever political stripe can abide this debasement of our profession and of the judiciary by this reckless demagogue. We all take an oath to “maintain the respect due to courts of justice and judicial officers” and I would hope that even the most rabidly partisan Republican colleague of mine in the bar would think twice before endorsing or backing Trump or ever voting for him.
Even though Judge Curiel has apparently ruled Trump’s way on various motions in the case, including granting the request by Trump’s lawyers to postpone the trial until after the election, that’s not good enough for Trump. It wasn’t enough to simply take exception to the judge’s latest ruling, but to attempt to smear the judge and accuse him of bias for having released the documents showing just what a consummate fraud Trump University really was.
Fortunately, even conservative lawyers like Josh Blackman, who transcribed Trump’s remarks about Curiel at Friday’s rally, have taken him to task saying “his jaw-dropping comments reflect an utter ignorance about what judges do and amounts to dangerous attacks on the fairness of our court system.” David Post, an adjunct at the conservative Cato Institute, wrote that Trump’s rant “is truly appalling and given that this guy could become president, terrifying.”
I’m hopeful that Republican lawyers in Indiana including those who serve in the Indiana legislature will also challenge this outrageous conduct and think twice about giving their endorsement to Trump. As David Post put so well in his column, “Our form of government will not work if the executive branch does not respect the legitimacy of decisions made by the judicial branch.”
Hoosier lawyers should echo the sentiments of Prof. Charles Geyh, a legal ethics expert at IU Law School who said very clearly to Reuters that Trump’s behavior could earn him “sanction for indirect criminal contempt of court. He has impugned the honesty of a judge in a pending case and has done so in the context of a political rally that seems calculated to intimidate by inciting anger among his supporters.”
Certainly, there’s a line that cannot be crossed and Hoosier lawyers – of all political stripes – must know that Trump has now crossed that line.
Shaw R. Friedman is former legal counsel for the Indiana Democratic Party and a longtime HPI columnist. He can be contacted at friedman@netnitco.net
Submit a comment
Please fill out the form below to submit a comment.
Comment
Message is a required field.
Your Name
Email
Phone
Captcha entry is not valid, please try again.
A comment must be approved by our staff before it will displayed on the website.
Submit
X
Pence visits Auschwitz for first time
“It seems to me to be a scene of unspeakable tragedy, reminding us what tyranny is capable of. But it seems to me also to be a scene of freedom’s victory. I traveled in our delegation with people who had family members who had been at Auschwitz — some had survived, some not. But to walk with them and think that two generations ago their forebears came there in box carts and that we would arrive in a motorcade in a free Poland and a Europe restored to freedom from tyranny is an extraordinary experience for us, and I’ll carry it with me the rest of our lives.”
-
Vice President Mike Pence
, who visited the Auschwitz concentration camp in Oswiecim, Poland on Friday along with
Second Lady Karen Pence
and Polish
President Andrzej Duda
and
First Lady Agata Kornhauser-Duda
. It was Pence's first time at the scene where Nazi Germany murdered more than 1.1 million Jews and other groups during the World War II Holocaust.
Our first national park at Indiana Dunes
It continues to amaze me how many folks from central and southern Indiana have never visited Indiana's sea, known to most of us as Lake Michigan. If you need another reason to take a couple hour trip northward on U.S. 31, U.S. 421 or I-65, thank
President Trump
for our first national park. It's now the Indiana Dunes National Park. The move was included in the spending package compromise that Trump signed on Friday, inserted in the legislation with the help of
U.S. Sen. Todd Young
and
U.S. Rep. Pete Visclosky.
Visclosky said, "I also am heartened that because of the support of our U.S. Senators, the entire Indiana Congressional delegation, and numerous Northwest Indiana organizations, we have successfully titled the first National Park in our state. This action provides our shoreline with the recognition it deserves, and I hope further builds momentum to improve open and public access to all of our region’s environmental wonders.”
The Dunes includes white sand beaches, trails and an array of flora and bogs, with a front row seat to the Chicago skyline. It richly deserves to be Indiana's first national park.
- Brian A. Howey, publisher
HPI Video Feed
Tweets by @hwypol
The HPI Breaking News App
is now available for iOS & Android!
Home
|
Login
|
Subscribe
|
About
|
Contact
© 2019 Howey Politics, All Rights Reserved • Software © 1998 - 2019
1up!
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##