Login
|
Subscribe
Search only accepts letters and numbers.
Monday, July 4, 2022
Home
News
Coronavirus Coverage
State & National Coverage
CDC Coronavirus Microsite
Columns
Brian Howey
Cameron Carter
Linda Chezem
Joshua Claybourn
Jack Colwell
Larry DeBoer
Craig Dunn
Trevor Foughty
Shaw Friedman
Christina Hale
Lee Hamilton
Kelly Hawes
Maureen Hayden
Michael Hicks
Rich James
Terri Jett
David Kitchell
Robert Kraft
Anne Laker
Erin Macey
Morton Marcus
Jay Ruckelshaus
Chris Sautter
Mark Schoeff Jr.
Pete Seat
Curt Smith
Russ Stilwell
Mark Souder
Tony Samuel
Renee Wilmeth
Downloads
HPI Daily Wire
HPI Weekly PDF's
HPI Polling
HPI Poll April 23, 2013
Howey/DePauw Poll November 2, 2012
Howey-Gauge Poll October 28, 2008
Howey/DePauw Poll September 27, 2012
Howey/DePauw Poll May 4, 2012
Howey/DePauw Poll April 5, 2012
Howey-Gauge Poll September 4, 2008
Howey-Gauge Poll April 29, 2008
Member's Archives
2014 Archives - PDF's
2013 Archives - PDF'S
2012 Archives - PDF's
2011 Archives - PDF's
2010 Archives - PDF's
2009 Archives - PDF's
2008 Archives - PDF's
2007 Archives - PDF's
2006 Archives - PDF's
2005 Archives - PDF's
2004 Archives - PDF's
2003 Archives - PDF's
2002 Archives - PDF's
2001 Archives - PDF's
2000 Archives - PDF's
HPI Videos
About
Contact
Subscribe
Jack Colwell: This column is for the birds
By JACK COLWELL
Thursday, February 24, 2022 9:26 AM
SOUTH BEND – This column is for the birds. For all of our feathered friends that perished mysteriously last summer. And for the organization with a strange name, Birds Aren’t Real, that seeks to explain a conspiracy against birds by our own government.
You remember those summer headlines: “Songbirds are dying across Indiana, and experts still don’t know why.” Could the explanation be found in the conspiracy theory of Birds Aren’t Real, a movement with credibility matching that of QAnon?
Here’s the theory: The U.S. government practiced bird genocide. Why? So real birds could be replaced with drone replicas flying all around to spy on us, listen to what we say, track where we go and record with whom we associate. The sparrow we think we see is a drone. Birds aren’t real.
Although these theorists contended that all real birds already were gone, some apparently survived until last summer. Then they were doomed, falling to the ground all over Indiana, with befuddled experts never suspecting that the government did them in.
Many of you no doubt find this bird-abolishing conspiracy too ridiculous to believe. But it does have three elements that convince a whole bunch of Americans to believe other conspiracy theories: 1) It’s on the internet, so it must be true; 2) It’s described as false by the mainstream media, so it must be true; 3) It’s based on belief that government is evil, so it must be true.
Well, Peter McIndoe, the 23-year-old creator of Birds Aren’t Real, reveals in a serious interview that he started the whole thing on a whim in 2017, writing the name of what was to become a movement on a sign that he carried in a protest march that had nothing to do with birds. It caught on through social media, especially with young Generation Z types who recognized a fun spoof. Thus began an experiment in using misinformation as a satirical attack on misinformation.
The message was expanded in social media, with an actor portraying a CIA agent confirming the bird genocide, and taken on the road, with a van festooned with such messages as “BIRDS CHARGE ON POWER LINES,” “PIGEONS ARE LIARS” and “WAKE UP.” Signs waved at rallies warned: “BIRD WATCHING GOES BOTH WAYS.”
Just like the My Pillow guy, the Birds Aren’t Real promoters sell merchandise as well as conspiracy. T-shirts with “If it flies, it spies” and other catchy messages are sold to help finance van travel.
Young Generation-Zers, with ever-present messaging and quick research, knew this was satire, use of a totally ridiculous conspiracy to poke fun at other silly conspiracies. What about some of the older Americans who listen only to messages of angry conspiracy theorists? After all, a conspiracy with the government using drones that look like birds to spy from the sky isn’t much more ridiculous than other conspiracy theories that capture rabid followings.
Examples: The contention that the shooting of those 20 first-graders at Sandy Hook school was faked, with little actors posed as slain victims. The Pizzagate story that Hillary Clinton and other political leaders were molesting kids held captive at a Washington pizzeria. The QAnon claim that John F. Kennedy Jr. didn’t die in a plane crash and will appear to help Donald Trump reclaim the presidency.
All three brought troubling responses. Parents of the slain Sandy Hook kids were cruelly harassed. A man fired an AR-15 rifle inside the pizzeria in a quest to free nonexistent captive children. Crowds waited for days for Kennedy to reappear in Dallas.
Birds Aren’t Real? That’s a funny spoof, using the ridiculous in a humorous way to make a point about ridiculousness of other conspiracy theories that aren’t funny.
Colwell is a South Bend Tribune columnist.
Submit A Comment
Please fill out the form below to submit a comment.
*
indicates a required field
Comment
*
Your Name
Email
Phone
A comment must be approved by our staff before it will displayed on the website.
Submit
X
Holcomb will sign 'any' abortion restriction; House GOP to caucus outside Statehouse
“I don’t have any red lines right now. It’s of paramount importance to me … that we must recognize that this issue is one of the most divisive by definition — when you look at where people fall in the nation — and that will require a thoughtful and respectful airing of where we all come from.”
-
Gov. Eric Holcomb
to the
Capital Chronicle
, saying he will sign any abortion restriction legislation when the General Assembly reconvenes in a special session on July 25. Informed and reliable sources tell Howey Politics Indiana that House Republicans will caucus outside the Statehouse at an undisclosed location on Tuesday July 5 to develop legislation.
HPI Video Feed
Tweets by @hwypol
The HPI Breaking News App
is now available for iOS & Android!
Home
|
Login
|
Subscribe
|
About
|
Contact
© 2022 Howey Politics, All Rights Reserved • Software © 1998 - 2022
1up!
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##